Romeo and Juliet Comparison Paper
William Shakespeare is undeniably one of the world's most revered authors and his work has survived the many changes that our culture and society have undergone. This, however, does not mean that Shakespeare's works should be marred and scarred by these changes that have occurred. This is exactly what has happened with the making of the 2000 movie version of Romeo+Juliet. The producers and screenplay writers have taken Shakespeare's work and changed it from his original desires. The movie claims to have taken Shakespeare’s characters and created them into more "modern" versions of themselves. In actuality, they have warped them into people that Shakespeare would not recognize as characters penned from his own hand. William Shakespeare’s play Romeo and Juliet is dissimilar to the movie version Romeo+Juliet due to vast differences in the character portrayals.
One thing that the movie changes are portrayals of minor characters, primarily the Nurse and Lady Capulet. In the play, Lady Capulet, as well as her husband, is seen as a distinguished figure of high wealth and social rank. This is shown through the way her family members, servants, and people associated with her family stay fiercely loyal to the Capulet name. Her two servants, Sampson and Gregory, are so loyal to her family that they go as far as starting a street brawl with servants of the Montague family to show their allegiance. To uphold this view that others have of her, Lady Capulet maintains a dignified persona. In the movie, however, she does not act in a dignified manner. At the Capulet ball, she is seen dressed in a very skimpy costume. While at the ball, she also drinks a great amount and acts in a very wild, undignified manner. People of that social rank would not act that way in public and still maintain their dignity and their position in the social hierarchy. While the Lady Capulet in the play displayed proper etiquette for a lady of her class, the Lady Capulet in the movie did not.
Another minor character that was changed was the Nurse. In the play, she is constantly making crude jokes to and about Juliet, which makes her seem like a rather disgusting old lady. In the movie, though, she doesn’t make jokes of that sort and is very loving towards Juliet. She portrays almost a grandmother-like character with her sweetness and kindness.
One main character difference was the portrayal of County Paris. The contrasts between the two versions of Paris provide differing views on which man Juliet should marry. The Paris in the play seems very pushy and arrogant. When talking with Lord Capulet he is always digressing to the topic of winning Juliet’s hand in marriage. Even after the death of Juliet’s cousin, Tybalt, Paris is only worried about receiving Lord Capulet’s permission to marry Juliet. This comes across as extremely pushy because the Capulet’s (save Juliet) are still in very deep mourning of the loss of their cousin. Paris gives himself a rude, selfish personality in the play. In the movie, Paris’s demeanor changes entirely. He has a much softer, gentler approach to gaining Lord Capulet’s approval. He is more patient in waiting for that approval as well. Paris is also shown as being very well dressed and groomed. He displays impeccable manners and does not engage in risky behaviors that harm his or others’ health. This leads people to infer that he would take better care of Juliet, should he receive her hand in marriage.
The biggest and most glaring difference in character portrayals is in the main character, Romeo Montague. The Romeo in the play seems more innocent and well-intentioned in his pursuit and eventual winning of Juliet’s love. He comes across as a “good kid” who is just trying to find someone that he loves that will reciprocate those feelings. In the play, Romeo is a likable character that wants Juliet’s love so much that a reader hopes that Juliet marries Romeo and turns down Paris’s proposal. Alternately, in the movie the feelings of the reader (or viewer) are interchanged. In the play, Romeo is a very unlikable character. His love for Juliet seems to be more about making him feel happy and satisfied than it is a true relationship where both partners show compassion to one another. Romeo also frequently smokes, and he and his best friends take drugs before illegitimately entering the Capulet ball. Romeo does not take very good care of himself, which shows no reason that he would take care of Juliet.
These differences in character portrayal ultimately make the tone of the movie different from that of the play. In the play, Shakespeare is telling the tale of two innocent lovers whose story reaches a tragic end due to fate. In the movie, the feeling changes dramatically. Juliet falls in love with Romeo, a boy that has many problems. This makes Paris the favorite in winning Juliet’s love because Romeo gives the impression that he could not adequately care for Juliet. Romeo and Juliet’s deaths come as a result of Romeo’s carelessness, not fate, as Shakespeare intended it to be. If Shakespeare were still alive today to see this movie, he would be distraught over how his work of art has been mutated.